Do Taller Hoods Cause Hundreds of Pedestrian Deaths a Year?
A New York Times analysis estimated taller hoods were tied to 200–400 pedestrian deaths a year, but those are model estimates, not proof of cause.
The short answer is that the analysis supports a link between taller hoods and hundreds of pedestrian deaths a year, but it does not prove that hood height alone caused each death. A New York Times analysis estimated that 200 to 400 pedestrians each year would not have died if vehicles had stayed roughly the size they were at the start of the century. Over 2016 through 2024, the analysis estimated about 3,000 deaths linked to the shift toward taller hoods.
Those figures come from a statistical model applied to federal crash data and from simulations. They are not a count of deaths confirmed to be caused by hood height.
What the analysis measured
The New York Times analysis used four main datasets:
- NHTSA Crash Report Sampling System data for 2016 through 2024.
- NHTSA Fatality Analysis Reporting System data.
- Vehicle measurements from Expert AutoStats.
- Vehicle registration data from S&P Global for 2002 through 2024.
The analysis then used a logistic regression—a statistical model that adjusts for differences among crashes—to limit the comparison to single-pedestrian, single-vehicle crashes. The model accounted for alcohol involvement, crash year, vehicle year, and the sex and age of the driver and pedestrian. Forensic Rock ran crash tests to support the work.
Why hood height and blind spots matter
The analysis points to two main vehicle-design factors. First, taller hoods raise the point of impact. In a lower car, a pedestrian may be pushed up onto the hood, which is designed to absorb some of the impact. With a taller hood, the impact point can be above a person’s center of gravity and push the person down toward the road instead.
Second, modern vehicles have larger A-pillars—the roof supports beside the windshield—to protect occupants in rollover crashes. The analysis says this can create larger blind spots than in vehicles sold around the turn of the century.
Forensic Rock’s Shawn Harrington described the result this way: “We see a lot of devastating collisions even at lower speeds because the pedestrian gets punted forward. Before the driver knows what’s happened, the pedestrian’s head is under the wheel.”
The analysis also used 3D scans of modern Chevrolet Silverado, Ford F-150, GMC Sierra, and Toyota Tacoma pickups and their 1990s or early 2000s counterparts. For hypothetical drivers 5 feet 11 inches and 5 feet 6 inches tall, the Silverado’s blind spots nearly doubled. The GMC and Toyota blind spots increased by about 60 percent, and the F-150 by about 25 percent. These comparisons were for specific pickups, not every vehicle.
Key estimates
| Measure | Estimate |
|---|---|
| Extra pedestrian deaths linked to taller hoods, 2016–2024 | About 3,000, described as conservative |
| Deaths per year that would have been avoided if vehicles stayed roughly turn-of-the-century size | 200 to 400 |
| Share of the recent increase in pedestrian deaths | About 10 percent |
| Change in the odds of a pedestrian fatality per 1-inch increase in hood height | 2.8 percent higher odds in the model |
| Lives that could have been saved in simulations, 2016–2024 | 2,624 with random 2002 hood heights; 3,077 with every hood 3 inches lower |
What the estimates do not prove
The analysis is observational. It adjusts for several factors, but it cannot prove that hood height alone caused any single death.
The 2.8 percent figure is a change in odds in a model. It is not a simple statement that a 1-inch taller hood raises a particular pedestrian’s chance of dying by 2.8 percent.
The roughly 3,000 estimate is limited to crashes in the federal data. The analysis notes that parking lots, driveways, and private roads are not in that database, so it calls its count conservative. Those locations are outside the estimate.
The simulation results depend on the scenarios chosen: lowering every hood by 3 inches or randomly sampling 2002 hood heights across 10,000 simulated crashes. They are what-if estimates, not recorded outcomes.
The analysis attributes about 10 percent of the recent increase in pedestrian deaths to the hood-height shift. It does not attribute the full rise to hood height. It also does not identify a safe hood height or a threshold below which pedestrian risk disappears.
comment